A 3-Year-Old Struggles with Sibling’s Birth

March 12th, 2013

by Katrina Brooke

I’ve read Dr. Brazelton’s book, Understanding Sibling Rivalry, but I need additional information about how to help our 3-year-old daughter who is having separation anxiety after the birth of a sibling.

Often, when a child is experiencing separation anxiety, a parent is too. I can make any mother cry when she announces a second pregnancy to me. All I have to say is what she is feeling but can’t quite face: “You will be deserting that older child.”

She’ll start weeping, but as we talk, she realizes that she must face these feelings if she is to be able to help the first child put this new family member into perspective.

On some level, the mother-to-be may identify with the older child’s feelings: “How could you do this to me?” translates into “How could I impose a second child on the first?”

But until she is able to answer this question for herself, she will find it difficult to answer it for the child. As long as she doubts this decision, and fears that she really is “harming” the first child, then this is the unnerving message that child is likely to receive. The child isn’t likely to forgive the mother for this “abandonment” until she can stop seeing it this way, until she can forgive herself.

Parents always worry in second or later pregnancies, “Will I have enough to go around for another child?” But of course they will. Children learn to adjust to new siblings as they come along. This adjustment can teach them important lessons that they will need to get along in the world later on, for example, that the world does not revolve around them.

Siblings get so much from each other in the way of learning (learning how to compete, how to resent a sibling ,and yet to love the other anyway). They learn to share and care for each other.

Just watch the younger one imitate the older one in learning a new developmental step. The younger one will watch and watch, then put the whole step together all from imitation and from modeling on the older one: “visual learning.”

Giving a child a sibling is like giving him a gift. But don’t expect the older child to thank you when you bring your new baby home. She won’t recognize the gift of this unique new relationship until much later on.

Preparation for the new baby while you are pregnant will help you and your first child face the “separation.” For you the “separation” from her will be an emotional one so much of your energy will be called up to focus on the new baby. Already your 3-year-old can feel the family’s attention begin to shift away from her.

But you can involve her in this new family event too: “Feel mommy’s tummy. Can you feel the baby you and I will take care of? This will be your baby as well as mine.”

Play out the nurturing with a toy or a doll. Show the older child how to cuddle and feed a beloved baby doll beforehand. She may even want to diaper it. “Now you know how to love the baby like your doll or your truck. You can help me when we have a baby.”

For your 3-year-old, though, the separation she is most worried about is the time when you will go to the hospital. It’s all so mysterious, and so hard to explain.

What will happen? Will you be OK? Will you come back? To help prepare her, you must let your daughter know who will be with her while you are giving birth to the new baby. Encourage her to talk with that important person (her father, a grandparent) beforehand to plan it all out. Then, when you come home, let your daughter help with the new baby as you’ve rehearsed.

You might also take a new special stuffed animal or a doll home with the new baby so that 3-year-old can nurture it, imitating you with the new baby.

But don’t expect your oldest child to share your enthusiasm for the new baby right away. Even if she does at first, the novelty will soon fade. Sulking, temper tantrums and the temporary re-emergence of other old behaviors are predictable.

Don’t pressure her to be a “big” sister, and don’t overdo the praise when she does try to nurture the new baby. Instead, let her know that she will always be your first baby, and that if she feels like being a baby sometimes now too, that’s OK with you. She’s far more likely to step into these big new shoes if you let her step into them herself, when she’s ready.


bNS_thumbnail.jpg© Copyright 2013. All rights reserved by Joshua Sparrow MD and T. Berry Brazelton MD.

Comments Closed

About The Shyne School
Message Board
Coming Events
Download our annual Calendar for Shyne Calendar 2022 to 2023

Updated 1/30/2023 – Updates to calendars sent to current parents with Lesson Plans and Newsletters as well as posted in the lobby.

*We follow the NSD calendar for breaks. We

Read more
Important Information

Tuesday, Dec 20, 2022 The Shyne School will be closed due to furnace issue and snow.

We will be closed Wednesday, Dec 21, 2022 to have a new furnace installed.
With freezing temps and more snow on the way tonight, …
Read more
Tour Our School

When we are full we do not offer tours.  Once we have an opening I will call from the waiting list and set up an individual tour, by appointment.  Once a family has toured they can decide if they wish …

Read more